Advisories
Google Fined €403 Million by Irish DPC Over Misleading Location Tracking Controls
Ireland's Data Protection Commission has penalized Google €403 million following a six-year investigation into how user location data was gathered and utilized between 2018 and 2020. The inquiry revealed that disabling the Location History setting failed to halt telemetry collection through separate configurations like Web & App Activity.
What Happened
The Irish Data Protection Commission (DPC) concluded a multi-year statutory inquiry into Google's handling of user telemetry. Investigators determined that between May 2018 and February 2020, Google collected geolocation data without providing clear notice that the information was being repurposed to infer user interests and target advertisements. The probe originated from a 2018 investigative report highlighting that disabling the primary 'Location History' toggle did not completely stop devices from logging and storing location coordinates.
Impact
The regulatory action stems from overlapping data collection mechanisms where independent account settings operated without user awareness. Specifically, the 'Web & App Activity' setting continued to capture and store geographic data independently of the Location History preference. This opaque behavior resulted in substantial legal liabilities globally, including multi-state settlements in the United States totaling hundreds of millions of dollars prior to this European enforcement action.
What Defenders Should Do
- Audit enterprise and personal account configurations to understand how separate telemetry settings interact.
- Verify that privacy controls span all dependent application features rather than relying on a single master toggle.
- Review organizational data retention policies regarding device tracking and endpoint geolocation services.